-
-
Writers
-
Categories
-
Recent Comments
- Julie Sheppard on The Doubt of the Benefit: Fake Progress and Lumosity’s “Brain Games”
- Logan Feeney on How I Helped Destroy Star Wars Galaxies
- taolataohoideolamthe on Call of Apathy: Violent Young Men and Our Place in War
- Christopher Robles on Interview: Kyrie Ru of Overture Interactive
- Tobi Alafin on The Doubt of the Benefit: Fake Progress and Lumosity’s “Brain Games”
-
Medium Difficulty Tweets
-
Featured Posts
-
Response: Kicking and Screaming: Penny Arcade and Kickstarter
31 July 2012 -
On Unification: Tying the Room Together
11 May 2012 -
I’d Rather Be Mauled by a Bear Than Save the World
15 March 2012 -
Heart of Darkness: E3, Violence, and Context for Outrage
8 June 2012 -
Gotcha!: An ARG Story
20 October 2013
-
-
Meta
- Entries RSS
- WordPress.org
Tag Archives: Formalism
What’s Wrong With Game Reviews?
What’s wrong with game reviews? I could complain what a useless measure game scores have become, since the current range of 8-10 scores is too restricted to have any meaning. Imagine how difficult it would be to talk about height if everybody’s height was described as a number between eight and ten. Worse, I find that the most interesting games tend to score in about the 85s, so imagine that sometimes people who were 10 feet tall were actually shorter than people who were eight feet tall. Even if the range of scores were better distributed, though, it still seems like the least interesting titles would still rise to the top. Why is that? Continue reading →
Posted in
Criticism
,
Features
,
Round Table
|
Tagged
badgame
,
Citizen Kane
,
Dragon Age 2
,
Fallout: New Vegas
,
Formalism
,
Games Criticism
,
Grand Theft Auto 4
,
Joseph Hilgard
,
Lana Del Ray
,
Metacritic
,
metacriticism
,
New Games Journalism
,
Orson Welles
,
PC Gamer
,
Rich McCormick
,
Roger Ebert
,
S.T.A.L.K.E.R.: Call of Pripyat
|
4 Comments