Gamer Profiles: The Split-screener

Image from techworld24.com

Image from techworld24.com

I don’t have a lot in common with Francis Underwood. He is the majority whip for the Democrats; I am an English major. He is known for aggressive politics and cunning stratagems; in Tic-Tac-Toe, I am known for giving up victories in the name of preserving the symmetry of the board. He is a fictional character played masterfully by Kevin Spacey; I am a nonfictional character played with passing competence by myself.

But there is one thing that Mr. Underwood and I have in common: we both play videogames.

I became increasingly acquainted with Francis Underwood and the rest of the characters in Netflix’s House of Cards over the course of a few days following a surgical operation. Nothing major—just the pulling of two impacted wisdom teeth that were left in place longer than any measure of wisdom would allow. But the combination of the pain and the painkillers left me unable to focus on my work, and on my usual distractions. Focusing on any one thing, in fact, was pretty much beyond me. I needed something to do, but any one thing seemed to little. So while I was watching Spacey deliver soliloquys to the audience from my laptop screen, I was also glancing to the TV screen on my left, where I was guiding engineer Isaac Clarke through a monster-infested space station in Dead Space . In my drug-induced haze, I felt a strong bond with Francis Underwood—not only did we both play videogames, but we were playing them at the same time.

While the intensity of this play-viewing (compressing a season of television and a playthrough of Dead Space into a handful of days) was unusual for me, the combination was not. As such, I would like to call for a new entry into the gamer profile series, one that encompasses such a playing style: my name is Michael Hancock, and I am a split-screener.

By split-screener, I don’t mean that I play games that divide the screen into portions, ala Mario Kart . What I mean is that when playing a game, I’m rarely just looking at the screen in front of me—usually, my attention is on some other screen at the same time, and I flit back and forth between the two. And I can offer many examples beyond just the House of Cards and Dead Space pairing. I went through Battlestar Galactica while playing Elder Scrolls: Oblivion . I fought through the mind-warping storyline of Nier while watching the time-warping storylines of Being Erica. I even double-downed on my game screens and switched back and forth between Etrian Odyssey and Persona 3 ; the advantage of a turn-based RPG is that you can put it down between turns to do something else, even if that something else is another turn-based RPG.

being_nier

It should be noted here that when I say screen, I’m taking it not as a physical screen, but screen in the sense of partition, a division of attention. Split-screening isn’t just dividing attention between two different physicals screens—sometimes, it’s dividing attention among different media in general. Take books and games; I read Holly Luhning’s  Quiver  while playing through  999: Nine Hours, Nine Persons, Nine Doors , and the violent horrors of both fed into each other in a very satisfying, complementary manner. (More complementary, than, say,  Nier  and  Being Erica ) In another literary DS pairing, the harsh, sacrifice-based mechanics of  Valkyrie Profile: Plume of the Covenenant  reinforced the harsh, callous tone of Camus’  The Plague . When  VP  proved too hard for me, I gave up on  The Plague  too; it felt too far off the rhythm I’d started to keep going on one without the other.

Here’s a split-screening pair that I imagine is familiar to a lot of people, to the point where we stop thinking of it as a split at all: games and music. Microsoft realized that people want to determine their own soundtrack fairly early off, which is why the Xbox 360 allows you replace the game’s music with songs of your own choice. For me, that choice is an eclectic mix. Some rather questionable tastes, in music and games both, have led to some bizarre, but unalienable associations. The last dungeon of Grandia will always be associated with Vertical Horizon’s “Everything You Want.” Nelly Furtado’s “I Am Like a Bird” is matched with the forest fight in Final Fantasy Tactics. God help me, I’ll never be able to think of Crashed Warped without tying it in with No Doubt’s discography, and vice versa.

I probably take split-screening to an extreme, but I bet it’s more common than people would think. One of my former roommates had a routine: he’d come home from work, fire up the television with a show he was catching up on, and play a few rounds of Angry Birds . When I went home for Christmas, I saw my brother and his fiancee—both of whom would very strongly self-identify as non-gamers—play rounds and rounds of Words with Friends while winding down with a few episodes of Storage Wars. For a larger scale example, it could be argued that the Nintendo WiiU is a system made for the social split-screener, dividing attention between the big screen and the the touch screen. It’s like playing a mobile game, with all your friends around! I’ve seen people stop in mid-conversation, pull out their phones, and point it at the nearest person: What do you think that is, they demand, thus  Draw Something making an appearance at the bar scene. We put our games into places that fit into our lives. With the increased prevalence of social games and mobile games, and in general, games that are designed to be played in short, sharp bursts, we are all turning into split-screeners.

The question is whether this is a good thing, and what split-screening means for the future of gaming and society at large. It’s easy to argue the con-side, that split-screeners engage everything on a more shallow level, so intent in maximizing their time that the true meaning—for whatever given value you want to assign to “true”–is buried in dissonant noise. Under this argument, the split-screener is the one who always selects “Maybe” on the great Facebook list of life’s events, a person so afraid to commit to one experience that they miss out on a little bit of everything. One response to this accusation is that no one is just a split-screener; we all have activities we place greater value on than others, and we respond as we see fit. Sometimes you want to sit down and read a book, sometimes you want to play a game, and sometimes, you want to do both; different entertainments afford themselves to different modes of engagements, and one does not preclude the value of another.

A better response, though, is that the split-screener, far from receiving a lesser gaming experience, embodies a greater truth: no man is an island, and no one games in a vacuum. When we play, we bring our cultural tropes with us, evaluating the game through the story forms we’re familiar with, the mechanics we understand. We bring our reasons for playing, whether that’s escapism, desire for dominance, connecting with friends, or a plethora of other possibilities. We bring our politics, our social values, our ideologies. In short, we bring ourselves. The split-screener, by visibly showing attention being divided among different mediums, demonstrates that our attention is always divided, always split between the game at hand, and our lives everywhere else. No one who plays games is just a gamer, and the split-screener—whether they’re an English student or a majority whip–knows that better than most.

My name is Michael Hancock. I’m a split-screener. Are you?

This entry was posted in Gamer Profiles and tagged 999: Nine Hours Nine Persons Nine Doors , Angry Birds , , Being Erica , Crashed Warped , , Draw Something , Elder Scrolls: Oblivion , Etrian Odyssey , , Gamer profiles , Grandia , House of Cards , Mario Kart , Michael Hancock , Nier , No Doubt , Persona 3 , Quiver , , splitscreen gaming , Storage Wars , The Plague , turn-based RPG , Valkyrie Profile: Plume of the Covenenant , Vertical Horizon , Words With Friends . Bookmark the permalink .
  • This is pretty much how my fiancee and I spend our evenings: something on Netflix or DVD and my laptop or 3DS on my lap. It’s probably less radical than saying Pokemon Black will forever be linked to the entire Fast & Furious movie franchise, but I cannot re-read House of Leaves without hearing Dillinger Escape Plan’s Miss Machine album (or vice versa.) Certain episodes of West Wing will forever by linked to Magical Diary, and Season 2 of Game of Thrones has recently become pretty associated with my learning the ropes (strings?) in Twine.

  • ed

    this is along the same lines as adhd entertainment and general phone rudeness in public for me.. try focussing on one thing

    • Michael Hancock

      I’ll admit, it drives me crazy when I’m having a one-on-one conversation with someone and they start paying more attention to their phone than the conversation. But it’s a very subjective thing, and how much it bothers a person seems to vary a lot. Honestly, I think focus is a lot more divided than we generally think it is–the human mind (or maybe just my mind) works associatively or paradigmatically rather than in systematic or syntagmatic ways. And you can probably see my English background poking through when I cite decades-old semiotic theory over recent cognitive theory.

  • The human brain isn’t really built to multitask like this – or at all, really. Engaging media like this doesn’t just lessen the depth of interaction with your chosen medium in a theoretical, critical way – it vastly lowers any meaningful intake in a pretty concrete way with a lot of science to back it up.

    • http://www.mediumdifficulty.com/ Kyle Carpenter

      While I certainly believe you that the studies are there to suggest that splitting ones attention drastically reduces what one is capable of focusing on, I want to point out one of your assumptions: that media demand our whole attention. For my part, I find that, say, many television dramas only require the most cursory degree of investment to be satisfying – especially since narrative genres allow someone to guess pretty readily where a story is going in a lot of cases. I think it’s worth noting that “enjoyment” can survive a hell of a lot of informational noise, and doesn’t require a high degree of, say, audio/visual fidelity to function.

      • Actually, you’re right, I think I framed it as way more black and white than it actually is. When I typically think of either scientific or anecdotal information about multitasking, it’s in the form of productivity of some sort where if you aren’t giving 100% effort, it might as well be 0% effort. I’m sure there is a middle ground for games.. but in terms of games that have been made specifically to be played as kind of a side-diversion, like on my phone, I still can’t say that (personally) they’re as enjoyable or as deep an experience as I typically want out of games, even proportional to how much of my attention they’re commanding

        • Michael Hancock

          This probably goes without saying, but there’s a big difference between productivity and entertainment. (And even the productivity depends on the task–when something’s particularly boring or routine, sometimes a bit of of a change can increase attention.) It all depends what kind of engagement you’re looking for. Facebook games, for example, are designed to be asynchronous, and played with rather varying amounts of attention. On the other hand, I wouldn’t want to break up something like “War and Peace” with a game of Halo–both require a lot of focus, and don’t really work well with divided attention. In the particular case above, the combination of pain killers and tooth ache meant that, for a while, I couldn’t focus well on any one thing, and dividing my attention between Dead Space and House of Cards was just how I decided to cope with it.

  • dude

    Oh brother; another fucking nerd ranting on about “how playing games doesn’t make you a gamer”. There seems to be an epidemic of fat fucks with nothing better to do than sit on their asses and stare at a glowing screen all the while fantasizing about how they’re gonna write a fucking article to show that they’re more than your average couch potato. And now it seems that this malady has become so common place that lack of concentration is being lauded as a virtue…if this article is an attempt to come out as gay on your part I think it would have been better if you would have just come out and said it; as opposed to bragging on about how you can shit and smoke weed at the same time. Your drug-haze was probably caused by getting high on your own shit you arrogant fuck.